Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Fab Four Fans earns from qualifying purchases. Some links are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you, and it never changes what we recommend.

The Beatles: Revolver Special Edition (5CD Super Deluxe) review
Apple Records

The Beatles: Revolver Special Edition (5CD Super Deluxe)

9.6
Our Rating
starstarstarstarstar_half
Essential
Sound 5.0/5
Packaging 5.0/5
Extras 4.5/5
Value 4.5/5
Collectability 5.0/5
Price From
$140
Check Price on Amazon arrow_forward

Affiliate link. No extra cost to you

Our Verdict

The Reissue That Proved De-Mixing Works, and the Model Rubber Soul Now Follows

Revolver Special Edition is one of the best Beatles reissues to date. The de-mixed stereo finally lets Revolver sound as bold in stereo as it does in mono, the sessions discs are revealing, and the 100-page book is superb. The 5CD box is the best value; the 4LP set is for vinyl devotees.

At a Glance: Specifications

Release dateOctober 28, 2022
LabelApple Records
New stereo mixGiles Martin and Sam Okell
TechnologyDe-mixing developed by Peter Jackson's WingNut Films
Super deluxe formats5CD; 4LP + 7-inch EP
Other formats2CD deluxe (40-page book), 1CD, 1LP, digital, Dolby Atmos (streaming)
Super deluxe book100 pages
Original recordingEMI Studios, London, April 6 to June 21, 1966

What's in the Box

Revolver Special Edition was released by Apple on October 28, 2022, and its centrepiece is a new stereo mix by Giles Martin and Sam Okell, made possible by de-mixing technology developed by Peter Jackson's WingNut Films during work on The Beatles: Get Back. It was the first Beatles album before Sgt. Pepper to receive the full special-edition treatment, following Pepper (2017), the White Album (2018), Abbey Road (2019) and Let It Be (2021).

The super deluxe edition came as five CDs or as four LPs plus a 7-inch EP. It holds the new stereo mix, two discs (four LP sides) of session recordings and demos, the original mono mix, and an EP with new stereo mixes of 'Paperback Writer' and 'Rain', both recorded during the Revolver sessions, alongside remastered original mono mixes. The 2CD deluxe edition pairs the new mix with session highlights and the two single tracks, with a 40-page abridged book, and there are single CD and LP versions too. Mastering was handled by Miles Showell, Alex Wharton, Sean Magee and Thomas Hall.

The new mixes of the album and of 'Paperback Writer' and 'Rain' are also available on streaming services in Dolby Atmos. Unlike the Sgt. Pepper, White Album, Abbey Road and Let It Be boxes, there is no Blu-ray disc in the Revolver set, so Atmos listeners need to stream.

Sound and Mixing: Why De-Mixing Changed Everything

Revolver was recorded on four-track tape between April and June 1966, and many instruments were bounced together onto the same track. That limited how far any previous remix could go. Giles Martin had said publicly that he was waiting for the technology to improve before tackling Revolver. WingNut's machine-learning tools, first built to clean up the dialogue and music on the Get Back tapes, let him pull the drums, bass and guitars apart even where they shared a track.

The result is a stereo mix that finally holds its own against the mono. The original 1966 stereo often put the rhythm section hard to one side, which sounds lopsided on headphones; the new mix centres the vocals and gives Ringo's drums on 'Tomorrow Never Knows' and 'She Said She Said' real weight, while Paul's bass on 'Taxman' is clearer and easier to follow. Critics agreed. Annie Zaleski gave it five stars in The Guardian, noting how newly audible details bring out deeper meanings in the songs, and the set scored a perfect 100 on Metacritic from nine reviews. It also charted: number 2 in the UK and number 4 on the Billboard 200, remarkable for a 56-year-old album.

Some purists still prefer the original mono, and the box includes it, so no one has to choose. The mono is the version the Beatles and George Martin worked hardest on in 1966, with the band often present at the mono mixing sessions and largely absent from the stereo ones. A good way to compare is to pick three contrasting tracks, say 'Eleanor Rigby', 'I'm Only Sleeping' and 'Tomorrow Never Knows', and play each in mono and then in the new stereo. The differences go beyond placement: 'I'm Only Sleeping' in particular has long had audible variations in the backwards guitar between the mixes.

Start with 'Taxman' and 'Rain' in the new mix. They show off the de-mixing clearly, especially Paul's bass lines. For 'Paperback Writer', Geoff Emerick famously used a loudspeaker wired up as a microphone to capture a bigger bass sound.

The Sessions Discs: Highlights for Paul Fans

The two sessions discs are the heart of the box for longtime fans. They trace songs from early takes to finished versions, including take one of 'Tomorrow Never Knows', a songwriting work tape of 'Yellow Submarine' that shows the song began life as a slow, melancholy John Lennon idea before Paul reshaped it, and early versions of 'Got to Get You into My Life' recorded before the brass arrangement arrived.

For McCartney fans in particular, the sessions show Paul's growing confidence as a writer and arranger in 1966. 'Here, There and Everywhere', 'For No One', 'Eleanor Rigby' and 'Got to Get You into My Life' all date from these weeks. 'Eleanor Rigby' features no Beatle playing an instrument at all, only a double string quartet scored by George Martin, and 'For No One' pairs Paul's clavichord with Alan Civil's French horn solo, which Civil played at the top of the instrument's range.

The sessions discs are not a complete archive of every take, and some fans wished for more. But they are well chosen and well sequenced, with the most revealing material from the tapes presented in excellent sound.

Listening to the sessions in order also tells the story of a band changing its working methods. Revolver was the album where the Beatles leaned hardest into the studio as an instrument: backwards guitars, tape loops, varispeed and artificial double tracking all appear across these weeks. ADT was devised by EMI engineer Ken Townsend during these sessions, and Geoff Emerick, newly promoted to balance engineer at the age of 20, was helping the band find new sounds, such as recording Ringo's drums with the microphones close in and the bass drum muffled with a sweater.

Packaging and Extras: The 100-Page Book

The 100-page hardbound book in the super deluxe editions is one of the best in the series. It has a foreword by Paul McCartney, an introduction by Giles Martin, an essay by Questlove and detailed track notes by Kevin Howlett. It is illustrated with handwritten lyrics, tape boxes, recording sheets and 1966 print ads, along with extracts from Klaus Voormann's graphic novel Revolver 50: Birth of an Icon.

Voormann's original album artwork, which won the Grammy for Best Album Cover, Graphic Arts in 1967, has been restored, and the sleeve holding the session outtakes uses Robert Freeman's proposed alternative cover, with the Beatles' heads arranged in a psychedelic circle. It is a thoughtful touch for collectors, and a reminder that the famous line drawing was not the only design under consideration in 1966.

The 12 by 12 inch format matches the earlier special editions, so the set sits neatly on a shelf next to Pepper, the White Album, Abbey Road and Let It Be. The upcoming Rubber Soul Special Edition, out October 2, 2026, follows the same format.

Keep the 5CD box in its outer slipcase and store it upright. The book spine carries the weight of the discs, and flat storage under other boxes can warp it.

Which Format Should You Buy?

The 5CD super deluxe is the best value: every track, the full book, and discs you can rip. It launched at around $140 in the US and has often been discounted since. The 4LP plus 7-inch box costs considerably more and is aimed at vinyl collectors who want the album and sessions on LP with the larger artwork.

The 2CD deluxe edition is a sensible middle ground, with the new mix, session highlights, both single tracks and the 40-page book. The single LP and CD are for listeners who only want the new stereo mix. And if you have an Atmos system, remember that the Atmos mix is streaming only.

For a comparison with the other Beatles and McCartney boxes on the market, see our roundup of the best Beatles box sets. Our Abbey Road Anniversary Edition review covers the 2019 set in the same series.

Who It's For

Revolver Special Edition is for every Beatles fan who found the original 1966 stereo mix awkward, and for McCartney fans who want to hear the period when Paul's songwriting took a major leap forward, from 'Eleanor Rigby' to 'For No One'.

If you already own the 2009 mono and stereo remasters, the box still adds the new mix, the sessions, the EP and the book. For most fans, that is more than enough, and it is one of the few reissues we recommend without reservation.

It is also a good first purchase for anyone new to the Beatles' special edition series. Revolver runs about 35 minutes, and the gap between the old stereo and the new mix is easy to hear on ordinary speakers. Its songs also bridge two eras: the album was recorded weeks before the band's final tour, and it includes songs such as 'Tomorrow Never Knows' that they never attempted to play live. With the Rubber Soul set due on October 2, 2026, the two albums that link the early and late Beatles will both be available in expanded editions for the first time.

What We Loved

  • check_circleTransformative stereo remix made possible by de-mixing
  • check_circleTwo excellent sessions discs, including the 'Yellow Submarine' work tape
  • check_circleOriginal mono mix included
  • check_circleSuperb 100-page book with Paul's foreword and Questlove's essay

What to Watch

  • cancelNo Blu-ray; Dolby Atmos is streaming only
  • cancel4LP box is expensive
  • cancelSessions discs are a selection, not a complete archive
Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

October 28, 2022, on Apple Records. It came as a 5CD super deluxe, a 4LP plus 7-inch super deluxe, a 2CD deluxe, single CD and LP, and digitally, with the Dolby Atmos mix on streaming services.
Giles Martin and Sam Okell. They used de-mixing technology developed by Peter Jackson's WingNut Films for The Beatles: Get Back, which let them separate instruments that had been recorded together on the original four-track tapes.
The new stereo mix, two discs of sessions and demos, the original mono mix, an EP with new and mono mixes of 'Paperback Writer' and 'Rain', and a 100-page book. The book includes a foreword by Paul McCartney and an essay by Questlove.
No. Unlike the four previous special editions, Revolver has no Blu-ray disc, so the Dolby Atmos mix is available on streaming services only.
It reached number 2 in the UK and number 4 on the Billboard 200 in 2022. Critics were almost unanimous, and Metacritic recorded a score of 100.
The Fab Four Fans Team
Written by

The Fab Four Fans Team

Fan-run · 100,000-member community · Collectors and concert-goers

Written by the admins and longtime members of a 100,000-member Paul McCartney fan community. Collectors, concert-goers and people who will happily argue about the best Wings album.

Keep Reading

You Might Also Like

Free Weekly Newsletter

The Fab Four Fans Weekly

Every Friday: the week's news, new releases, tour updates and one deep cut worth rediscovering. Free, forever.

Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.

The Beatles: Revolver Special Edition (5CD Super Deluxe)
$140
Amazon →